Beauty companies, regulators and science communicators need to put scientific findings in context, speak consistently and listen to where misinformation is circulating, according to panelists at the Cosmetic, Toiletry and Perfumery Association's (CTPA) inaugural scientific conference.
The members-only event was held at Central Hall Westminster in London. It examined how scientific evidence, regulatory decision-making and public understanding can converge at a time of information overload and widespread misinformation in beauty.
Context as a communication tool
Caroline Rainsford, CTPA director of science, said strong science communication is key because people in different roles spend their days translating complex scientific information for audiences. In a panel on building trust through science communication, she said putting science into context for consumers is always helpful. She recalled a conversation with salon professionals about an ingredient banned in nail polish, where the context was that a person would need to wear two kilograms of nail polish to approach the level that causes harm.
Marc Pissavini, sun research lab director at Coty, agreed on the importance of context and said the Olympic swimming pool analogy can help communicate liquid relevance. At two litres a day, he said, it would take around 4,500 years to drink one Olympic swimming pool. Once that is explained, he said, people understand that a drop in a swimming pool is not a lot. To fight misinformation, the industry first has to explain and give consumers keys to measure or understand, he added.
Consistency, peer review and uncertainty
Pissavini said credibility in science requires consistency. He called for the industry to speak with one voice, shifting from individual claims to collective language, as pharmacy and large groups do, which he said could make the sector stronger. Wendy Middleton, chief scientific officer and director for science at the UK government's Office for Product Safety and Standards, said the one-voice concept was interesting but also raised the question of how scientists communicate with one another. She noted that credible science depends on critique and peer review, while saying the profession should be more cognisant of how it communicates.
Pissavini, who is also editor of the peer-reviewed International Journal of Cosmetic Science, said it is crucial that the scientific community keeps the peer review process. He identified challenges in finding reviewers and in communicating better with readers inside and outside the industry. Rainsford said the industry needs to work collectively to demystify what peer review means, because most people, including some industry members, do not understand how the process works. Transparency about the process will be important, she said.
Roger Pullin, head of chemicals policy and health at the UK's Chemical Industries Association, said technical terms and acronyms should be avoided where possible. Messages should be framed from the consumer's perspective and be precise and clear without losing the science, he said. That can be tricky with complex subjects such as risk-based exposure. He added that science is not necessarily black and white, and that companies should acknowledge uncertainties and be upfront about what is unknown rather than avoiding awkward questions.
Meeting audiences where they are
Claire Coleman, a journalist, editor and consultant on the science behind beauty, said efforts to correct misinformation should begin where it is found. People have to be met where they are and helped to understand, she said, adding that communicators should stand on the same platform as their audience. Middleton agreed that meeting people where they are is critical. In government, she said, there used to be much talk about hard-to-reach consumers, but they are not hard to reach; they are hard for the communicator to hear. Reaching consumers therefore requires taking more responsibility for listening, she said.
Coleman added that the beauty industry should recognise it will not convert or reach everyone. It should focus on the floating voters, she said, meaning consumers who are uncertain and looking to understand better rather than hard-liners. Emma Meredith, CTPA director-general, closed the event by saying that how the industry communicates science, and that it communicates it well, is critical.
