Instron Makes Case for High Strain Rate Testing in Crash Simulation Workflows

The testing machine maker argues that material data captured at impact-level loading speeds can narrow the gap between simulated and physical crash results.

Material data captured at impact-level loading speeds can make crash and impact simulations more representative of real component behaviour, according to Andrea Incardona, application engineer and product specialist at high strain rate testing machine manufacturer Instron.

In an article setting out the company's position, Incardona explains that many materials exhibit strain-rate-dependent properties: their mechanical response changes as loading speed rises. A material characterised under quasi-static conditions may therefore behave differently when subjected to a rapid impact or crash event. Relying only on conventional data, he argues, can leave a model unable to represent the conditions a part actually experiences.

SAE study puts numbers on the gap

Incardona points to a 2025 study published in the SAE International Journal of Materials and Manufacturing, titled “Influence of Strain Rate Effect on Mechanical and Crashworthiness Properties of CFRP Composite Structures”. According to his account, incorporating strain-rate-dependent material properties into crash simulations reduced the discrepancy between simulated and experimental results. The discrepancy in peak acceleration fell by 6.5 per cent, while mean acceleration and displacement discrepancies fell by 5.9 per cent and 6.3 per cent respectively.

The argument drawn from that result is that the relevance of material data matters as much as its quantity. Where strength, stiffness, deformation mechanisms or failure behaviour shift with increasing strain rate, a model built solely on conventional properties may not capture a rapid event.

Test windows measured in milliseconds

Depending on the material, specimen geometry and test method, materials can be characterised from quasi-static conditions up to strain rates approaching 1,000/s. Such tests can last only 3 to 10 milliseconds, which places demands on data acquisition: the system must resolve rapid changes in force and deformation within a very short window.

Instron says its high strain rate testing systems support data acquisition at up to 200 kHz. Digital image correlation (DIC) can add information about how strain develops across the specimen, and analysis tools can then support data processing and theoretical modelling. These are company statements about its own equipment rather than independently verified performance figures.

Selection and weight trade-offs

Conventional properties such as strength and stiffness do not necessarily show how a material will respond when loading becomes rapid. Two materials that appear comparable in conventional testing may diverge under high strain rate conditions. Characterising their dynamic behaviour allows engineers to consider how each candidate deforms, absorbs energy and ultimately fails under loading relevant to the application.

Incardona argues this matters most where performance must be balanced against weight. Understanding how candidate materials respond during rapid loading adds a layer of information alongside mechanical properties, helping engineers weigh weight, strength and energy absorption, with automotive crash structures and aerospace components given as examples.

Earlier in the development cycle

In the article's framing, dynamic characterisation forms part of a development loop: material behaviour is measured, incorporated into simulation, used to compare design options and then validated through physical testing. That positions testing as more than a final check on an existing design, with engineers able to use dynamic data earlier to judge whether a material is suitable and to refine a component design.

The conclusion offered is that material data is only as useful as its relevance to the conditions a component will face. The article does not detail specimen types, test standards or the specific conditions behind the quoted strain-rate range beyond noting their dependence on material, geometry and method.

PD

Petra Dahlberg

Petra Dahlberg covers thermal and fluid equipment in industrial plants, with a focus on industrial chillers, compressors, pumps, heat exchangers, and control valves. Her reporting favors measurable evidence such as flow rate, head, differential pressure, dew point, compressor specific power, and vibration, and it treats ISO 12100 and IEC 60204-1 as boundary references only where they genuinely apply. She supports process engineers, maintenance managers, and capital procurement teams comparing utility and fluid systems on energy use, spare parts, and total cost of ownership.