Knackeries halt fallen sheep and horse collections in Fallen Animal Scheme dispute

Animal Collectors' Association members stop collecting fallen sheep and horses and halt scrapie sampling as talks with the Department of Agriculture stall.

Knackeries affiliated with the Animal Collectors' Association (ACA) have stopped collecting fallen sheep and horses and are withholding related notifications, escalating a dispute with the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM) over the Fallen Animal Scheme as it enters a second week.

The ACA said that from this week its members will no longer collect fallen sheep and horses, and that knackeries will also not notify the department of on-farm animal deaths. The association's business case was submitted ahead of the Fallen Animal Scheme's expiry on September 30.

According to the ACA, fallen sheep collected by its affiliated operators have not been prepared and presented to DAFM veterinary staff for scrapie sampling since Monday, October 19. That step depends on knackery operators preparing and presenting carcasses to department vets.

The association said it had submitted a "comprehensive, sustainable business case" to the department before the scheme lapsed. It said the proposal set out mechanisms for a fair and workable scheme and included options intended to limit increases in the rates charged to farmers.

Instead of engaging constructively with those solutions, the ACA said, DAFM has repeated a historic pattern of waiting for schemes to fully expire, forcing knackery operators into an escalating reduction of vital services.

The ACA said it remains fully committed to providing an environmental and biosecurity service to Irish agriculture, and called on the department to return immediately with a meaningful proposal that protects the collection system's infrastructure without placing an additional burden on farmers.

A DAFM spokesperson said the Fallen Animal Scheme is an important element of Ireland's livestock infrastructure, through which department funding supports farmer access to fallen animal collections and protects animal health. The department said it is continuing to engage on the matter and remains open and available for constructive dialogue and negotiations.

Farm groups warn against extra costs

The Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers' Association (ICMSA) said any solution to the dispute "better not involve higher charges on farmers". Eamon Carroll, ICMSA deputy president, insisted that the answer must come from within the department's own funds.

The standstill affects two strands of the service: the physical collection of fallen sheep and horses, and the scrapie sampling chain that depends on knackery operators presenting carcasses to department vets. The ACA has described its action as a reduction of services, while DAFM says its lines of communication remain open.

The dispute centres on the terms and funding of the Fallen Animal Scheme, which the department says supports farmer access to collections and protects animal health.

NA

Noor Almeida

Noor Almeida is a farm equipment procurement and lifecycle analyst covering tractors, implements, harvesting and grain-handling machinery, agricultural tools, and biomass first-processing equipment. She compares documented PTO power, working width, effective field capacity, fuel use, service intervals, and spare-parts lead time under stated operating assumptions rather than relying on brand claims. She helps farm owners, procurement managers, and dealer service teams structure specification, maintenance, and total-cost decisions before purchase or fleet replacement.